Choosing a therapist is about finding someone who helps you feel seen, understood, and supported on your path to healing.
Finding the right therapist can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re already going through a difficult time. Whether you’re struggling with anxiety, relationship issues, or just feeling lost, starting therapy is a big step. If you’re looking for a therapist, this guide is here to help make the process a little easier so you can get the help you need.
Common Challenges When Looking for a Therapist
Let’s be honest—one of the biggest hurdles to finding a therapist is just getting in the door. You might need help now, but finding a therapist who has availability can take weeks, and that wait can feel discouraging. Beyond availability, it’s also important to find a therapist who specializes in what you’re experiencing. Not every therapist will have the right expertise for your needs, so narrowing down who can truly help you is key.
If you are using health insurance for your sessions, then there’s the challenge of navigating the insurance maze. You may find a therapist you like, only to discover they don’t accept your insurance. This can add another layer of stress to an already difficult situation. Knowing these challenges up front can help you prepare for them—and keep you from giving up before you find the right person.
Key Things to Consider When Choosing a therapist
The tackle the search process easily, you need to break the search process into two parts. In part one, you might want to clarify some basic questions that will simplify the search process.
Preparation Phase:
1. Do you prefer in-person sessions or online therapy?
Telehealth has made therapy more accessible, but some people still prefer face-to-face sessions. Figure out what’s most comfortable for you.
2. Do you have a gender preference?
Do you have a preference for the gender of your therapist? It’s perfectly okay to prefer a male, female, or non-binary therapist, or to have no preference at all. The most important thing is that you feel comfortable and supported in opening up.
3. What does your schedule look like?
Many therapists get booked during prime evening hours, so if you have flexibility during the day, you might have a better chance of securing an appointment. Some workplaces are more understanding now about taking time off for therapy, so you could even consider scheduling sessions during a lunch break, especially with telehealth.
4. How do you plan to pay for your sessions?
As we mentioned earlier, one of the most challenging parts of finding a therapist is navigating insurance. Understanding the basics of your health insurance can make this process smoother. Do you have a PPO or HMO plan? Are you aware of your deductible and out-of-pocket costs? Having this information ready for an intake call can simplify things significantly. For more details on PPOs, HMOs, deductibles, and out-of-pocket costs, check out our FAQ section on insurance.
The Search Phase:
5. Where to Start Your Search.
If you’re ready to find a therapist, the first step can be as simple as a Google search. For example, if you live in Wheaton Illinois, where our practice is located, typing “therapist in Wheaton” or “therapist near me” will give you a list of local options, and you can start exploring from there. Many therapists have profiles on sites like Psychology Today, where you can filter results based on location, specialty, and whether they accept insurance.
Your insurance provider’s website is another great place to check. If you’re using health insurance, it’s crucial to verify that the therapists you’re considering are covered. Websites like Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield, or Cigna offer directories where you can search for in-network therapists near you. This can save you time and ensure you won’t face unexpected costs down the road.
Also, don’t forget that your primary care doctor can be a valuable resource. They often have connections with local therapists and can refer you to someone who fits your needs. This can be a great way to find a therapist, especially if you’re unsure where to start.
6. Five Questions to Ask During a Consultation Call.
Once you’ve narrowed down some options, it’s a good idea to schedule a consultation or make an initial call to see if the therapist is the right fit. During this consultation, here are a few questions you might want to ask:
• Do you accept my insurance? This is one of the first things to clarify, especially if you plan to use insurance. Getting this out of the way early can prevent unnecessary stress.
• Have you worked with people dealing with concerns like mine? It’s important that the therapist has experience in handling the specific concerns you’re bringing in, whether it’s anxiety, depression, or relationship issues.
• What’s your availability like? If you need evening sessions, make sure they have those time slots available. If you’re open to daytime or telehealth options, let them know that too.
• Do you offer in-person or telehealth sessions? Depending on your preferences and comfort level, it’s good to confirm whether they offer sessions in the format that suits you best.
• How soon can I start therapy? This is an important question to ask to understand the waiting period. At Panahi Counseling in Wheaton, we strive to match clients with the right clinician who has the expertise and availability to accept new clients. During the consultation process, our intake specialist will typically gather some basic information to help find the best match for you.
7. Managing the Anxiety of Starting Therapy.
Many therapists get booked during prime evening hours, so if you have flexibility during the day, you might have a better chance of securing an appointment. Some workplaces are more understanding now about taking time off for therapy, so you could even consider scheduling sessions during a lunch break, especially with telehealth.
8. Don’t Give Up.
Searching for the right therapist can feel like a daunting process, but it’s worth it. Therapy has the potential to improve both your mental and physical health, enhance your relationships, and help you navigate life’s challenges.
By taking small steps—like searching online, checking your insurance provider’s directory, or scheduling a consultation—means you’re already on the right path. Finding a therapist doesn’t have to be overwhelming. With patience and persistence, you can find the support you need to start feeling better. If you’re in Illinois, contact us to see if Panahi Counseling is the right fit for you.
Share Post:
Start your therapy journey today.
Schedule a 15-Minute Free Consultation With Our Intake Coordinator.